My Memory is Broken. But I’m Not

My Memory is Broken. But I'm Not“She’s broken. Falling apart, scarred for life since her daughter died,” various friends and family members have said about me. This week I was going to write about how I didn’t feel “broken,” how I believed I was stronger and better than ever. But then I lost my mind. Briefly. Just memory failure, really. But the mortification still grinds in my head.

I was sitting with a friend at a table outside the gym when a beautiful young woman stopped by. “I’m Shoshana,” she said, smiling at me with familiar warm brown eyes. Immediately I recognized her as one of my daughter’s oldest friends.
“I’m so glad you came over,” I said, my heart laughing and crying as it does whenever I run into one of Marika’s BFFs. I’m always grateful when this happens. It takes courage to approach a bereaved mother; once old friends fled the aisle in Wegmans to avoid me. Shoshana set her coffee and croissant on the table, and sat down.

“I think of Marika a lot,” she said. And I thanked her for that, told her it meant everything to me that Marika was remembered. Shoshana mentioned what she’d been doing lately. That doesn’t sound like you, I said, and then shared a dozen details of what I remembered of her. Only, the images that popped up in my head were memories of a different girl, not the Shoshana sitting before me. I’d completely confused her with another of Marika’s friends.

Suddenly, we were saying goodbye. I mentioned one more thing that was totally not about Shoshana, and she looked at me like I had cracked.

She left. And for a moment I sat there disoriented, blinded by bright sunlight and shards of memories. And then I recalled the serious child who told silly jokes, the quirky kid who couldn’t carry a tune but was so giving, so eager to please. She was one of the few young friends that would look me straight in the eye. Her warm familiar eyes. The real Shoshana. I’d last seen her when she visited Marika in the hospital.

I caught up with her. Still dazed, I tried to explain. But there is no way to account for the brokenness of a mind that can recall every detail of a daughter’s last years, and yearns to have that daughter remembered, but cannot keep the other pieces of the past straight.

If you see me on the street, in the gym or at Wegmans, please say hi. I will not break if you mention my daughter. Chances are she’s already at the foreground of my thoughts. Besides, when it comes to brokenness, we’re all on a spectrum. And a broken memory doesn’t mean you’re a broken person. So forgive me if I don’t remember your name. I know who you are. Mostly. It’s in your eyes and your smile.

Share Button

4 thoughts on “My Memory is Broken. But I’m Not

  1. Elaine Mansfield

    This is so human and ordinary–except when we already feel like we’ve lost our minds. I’ve had women who were in my health care classes. I know I know them, but that seems like a previous life. I’m always so grateful when these smiling faces go on to explain our connection.

    You are not broken. A year or so after Vic died, a man said to me, “We didn’t think you were going to make it.” Who was that we? And who thought that of me? Couldn’t they see the warrior in me, even with tears running down my cheeks? Couldn’t they see there is no choice? Sending you lots of love. I won’t forget you, but it’s OK if you don’t recognize me. I’ll tell you about things we’d rather both forget from the oncology ward at Strong.

    1. Robin Botie Post author

      Don’t worry, Elaine. There’s no way I could forget you. I even remember the great-smelling green food you prepared in the kitchen at Strong all those years ago. I don’t know how much I’ve forgotten about Strong. I actually kinda like remembering those days because that’s when Marika was still alive. As I read and reread my memoir I look forward to her “coming alive” again on those pages. So I don’t know what it is I could possibly rather forget. Although I have not gone back to Strong, to the oncology ward where sooner or later I will probably have a friend to visit. I keep promising myself I will return before I have to visit a sick friend. But it hasn’t happened yet. I wonder if you’ve gone back there at all since Vic died?


    We could meet in Wegs and pretend we don’t know each other at all. I wonder, when we lose our memories more and more with age, how it will be. To see a familiar face and not know for sure if this is/was a friend, or maybe someone we hated. Or who hated us. It’s like we get to assess all over again what our relationship to this person standing before us will be.
    Well anyway, happy travels Lucy.

  3. Lucy Bergstrom

    Hi Robin,
    If I run into you in Wegman’s and you don’t recognize me, I’ll say, “It’s great to see you, Marianne!” Then we can both laugh.
    See you soon! I’m leaving in the morning.
    Love, Lucy


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *